When creating a backyard oasis, homeowners often face an important decision: swim spa vs. pool—which is better?
Pools have been a staple for decades, offering a large, open swimming space for recreation, relaxation, and exercise. However, swim spas are gaining popularity due to their compact design, lower maintenance needs, and multi-functional benefits. If you’re debating between a swim spa or a pool, understanding the key differences can help you make an informed choice.
Below, we break down the primary factors that distinguish these two options so you can determine which is the best fit for your home.
What Are Swim Spas?
A swim spa is a hybrid between a swimming pool and a hot tub, designed to provide a continuous water current that allows users to swim in place.
Unlike traditional pools, which require significant space, swim spas are compact and self-contained, making them an ideal choice for smaller backyards. These units come with adjustable jets that create a controlled water flow, providing resistance for swimming, aquatic workouts, and hydrotherapy. However, they require regular maintenance, including filter cleaning and chemical balancing, similar to traditional pools.
What Are Traditional Pools?
Traditional pools come in two primary types: above-ground and in-ground pools. These pools have been popular for decades, offering homeowners a dedicated space for swimming, exercise, and social gatherings.
- Above-ground pools are generally more affordable and easier to install. Some models are quite durable, especially those with reinforced materials. Aesthetic appeal can also be enhanced with proper landscaping and decking.
- In-ground pools provide a more permanent and luxurious solution, but they require professional installation, excavation, and customization.
Swim Spa vs. Traditional Pools – Key Differences
Choosing between a swim spa, in-ground pool, or above-ground pool depends on several factors. Below, we discuss eight essential aspects to consider before making your decision.
1. Size and Space Requirements
One of the biggest advantages of a swim spa vs. a traditional pool is its compact size. Swim spas typically range from 12 to 20 feet long and about 8 feet in width, making them a great option for homeowners with limited outdoor space.
Because of their smaller footprint, swim spas can fit in patios, decks, and even indoor spaces. In contrast, traditional pools require significantly more backyard space.
- In-ground pools can be as large as 40 feet long and require additional room for decking, landscaping, and safety barriers.
- Above-ground pools also need space for structural support and filtration systems.
If backyard space is limited, a swim spa might be the better choice.
2. Installation Time and Complexity
The pool installation process varies depending on the type of pool.
- In-ground pools require excavation, plumbing, and construction, which can take weeks or even months. They also require permits and inspections.
- Above-ground pools are quicker to install, but they still need a stable base, professional assembly, and proper filtration setup.
- Swim spas are pre-manufactured and can often be installed within a few days, though factors like foundation preparation, electrical connections, and site leveling can add to the timeframe.
3. Year-Round Usability
One major factor in the swim spa vs. pool debate is whether you want a year-round swimming experience.
- Traditional pools are often seasonal, especially in regions with cold climates. While pool heating systems can be installed, they increase energy consumption and operating costs.
- Swim spas have built-in heating systems, making them usable in all seasons, even during winter.
4. Swim Current Technology
One of the defining features of a swim spa is its built-in swim current system, which allows users to swim in place against a controlled current.
- This feature is beneficial for fitness training and simulates the experience of lap swimming.
- Traditional pools do not come with this feature by default, though swim jets or wave machines can be installed separately.
While swim spas are great for resistance training, professional swimmers may still prefer a full-sized pool for lap training, as the limited space in a swim spa may not fully replicate natural swimming movements.
5. Maintenance and Operating Costs
Maintenance is a key factor when choosing between a swim spa and a pool.
- Traditional pools require regular cleaning, chemical treatments, and filtration maintenance.
- Swim spas use less water, making them easier to maintain, but they still require proper sanitization, filter cleaning, and chemical balancing.
Larger pools consume more water and energy, leading to higher maintenance costs, while swim spas are generally more cost-effective.
6. Heating Efficiency
- Heating an in-ground or above-ground pool requires significant energy and time, leading to higher electricity costs.
- Swim spas are designed with insulated heating systems that retain warmth more efficiently, making them a cost-effective option for year-round use.
However, frequent use of swim spa jets and heating elements can still lead to higher energy bills, depending on usage patterns.
7. Versatility and Multi-Functionality
Unlike traditional pools, swim spas combine:
- Swimming
- Hydrotherapy
- Relaxation
Many swim spas include adjustable water currents, ergonomic seating, and built-in massage jets.
While traditional pools are great for recreation, they lack the therapeutic features of swim spas. If you’re looking for a multi-purpose water feature that supports exercise, relaxation, and therapy, a swim spa is a better choice.
8. Portability and Relocation Options
One major downside of in-ground pools is that they are permanent.
- Once installed, you cannot move them if you decide to relocate.
- Swim spas, on the other hand, are portable. If you move homes or rearrange your outdoor setup, a swim spa can be relocated, making it a flexible investment.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a swim spa and a traditional pool depends on your needs, available space, and budget.
- Traditional pools offer a larger swimming area, making them ideal for families, social gatherings, and full-body swimming exercises. However, they come with higher costs, longer installation times, and greater maintenance requirements.
- Swim spas, on the other hand, offer a compact, energy-efficient, and versatile solution for fitness, relaxation, and therapy. They are easier to maintain and can be used year-round.
Expert Pool Installation in Omaha
If you’re looking for reliable pool installation services in Omaha, contact Outdoor Living LLC for professional swimming pool contractors!
